Welcome to Cotton Exchange
Cotton Exchange, located at 345 Hickory Hollow Rd, Waterford, WI, is a standout dining destination known for its exceptional service and delectable cuisine. Guests rave about the tender steaks and innovative dishes like chili salmon, accompanied by fresh, seasonal vegetables. The friendly and attentive staff create a welcoming atmosphere, making every visit memorable. Whether enjoying a cocktail such as the famous pineapple upside-down martini or celebrating special occasions, patrons consistently praise the cleanliness and overall ambiance. Cotton Exchange is not just a restaurant; it’s a vibrant dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.
Cotton Exchange: Reviews & Ratings
At the Cotton Exchange as a wedding vendor. Having a blast partying and celebrating the newlyweds tonight. The venue is amazing and the staff is so friendly and attentive to the guests' needs! Was great working with them tonight. Clean bathrooms, clean bar, excellent food. Can't wait to come back! Julie Ring Tunes Photobooth assistant
The steaks are ALWAYS tender and well cooked. The drinks are reasonably priced and amazing, especially the pineapple upside-down martini! The staff is super friendly! One of our favorite restaurants!
The chili salmon was delicious. It had oriental veggies on it and most restaurants serve them from a frozen bag. Not these. Fresh carrots, zucchini and in the sauce they were amazing. Had green beans with them instead of a potato. I couldn't even finish it all. Got a doggie bag.
This restaurant is amazing! But overall thing that was out of this world and will bring us back every time the service is amazing! Our server Bonnie was so kind and accommodating! The best out there!! God bless you all, pray that you all are happy and healthy! Keep doing what your doing!
1st time here!! WONDERFUL experience!! DAVE the bartender was AMAZING and went above and beyond!! DEFINITELY will return!!
Delicious food! Fast, friendly, and helpful service. Fun atmosphere and great place to eat. Family and kid friendly. Everything we ordered was incredible! I had the Fried Fish.... It came with 4 pieces of cod, 2 potato pancakes, bread, coleslaw, apple sauce, and tartar sauce... I was stuffed! I can’t wait to come back. I highly recommend eating at the Cotton Exchange.
It's been a minute since I've eaten here last. The seafood was good, steak flavor was delicious. I felt the server could have been more friendly. The busser had more personality than the waitress. Hoping maybe she had an off night. It seemed quiet in there & expected a better serving experience for the price. I'd give the specialty drinks an A. Great drink menu!!
This restaurant is amazing. The food is very fresh with fantastic taste and flavors. We came for Sunday morning brunch. I ordered an omlet with everything. This is the best omlet I've ever had. We will be very frequent return customers :)
Location
-
345 Hickory Hollow Rd, Waterford, WI 53185, United States Hotline: +1 262-534-9291
Welcome to Cotton Exchange, a remarkable dining experience nestled at 345 Hickory Hollow Rd in Waterford, Wisconsin. This establishment is not just a place to eat; it's where culinary excellence meets warm hospitality. Whether you're celebrating a wedding or enjoying a casual dinner, Cotton Exchange provides an atmosphere that feels both polished and inviting.
Customers rave about their experiences here, and it’s no wonder. Julie A. highlighted her recent time here as a wedding vendor, praising the venue’s vibrant ambiance and the staff's attentive service. Cleanliness is a top priority, with patrons consistently pointing out the spotless bathrooms and bar area, ensuring comfort throughout your visit.
Another standout feature of Cotton Exchange is its culinary offerings. Renee Martin commends the tender steaks, expertly cooked to perfection. You'll find that the drink menu is equally impressive, featuring unique concoctions like the pineapple upside-down martini, which adds a delightful twist to any night out.
Moving beyond steak, Sherry Aukland's experience with the chili salmon showcases the restaurant's commitment to freshness. Instead of relying on frozen vegetables, Cotton Exchange serves vibrant, seasonal produce that elevates the dish. With options like fresh green beans instead of typical starchy sides, it’s clear that the menu is designed with care.
Exceptional service remains a hallmark of Cotton Exchange. Emily was particularly impressed by her server, Bonnie, whose kindness and attentiveness transformed a solid meal into an extraordinary experience. The warmth of the staff is a recurring theme in customer reviews, noted time and again as a reason to return.
From the moment you step into Cotton Exchange, you can expect a truly wonderful experience, much like that of first-time visitor Tami Payne. With standout bartenders like Dave going above and beyond to enhance your evening, it's easy to see why many consider Cotton Exchange a favorite dining destination. Whether it's the impressive menu or the welcoming staff, every visit feels special.
So, if you're in Waterford, don't miss the opportunity to savor what Cotton Exchange has to offer—it's a gastronomic journey that promises to impress with every dish and delightful moment.